Tuesday, June 16, 2026
Sign In
★ ★ ★

Conservatives Daily

Independent Reporting · Est. 2020
BackPolitics

Thune Defies Trump on FISA Renewal as Senate Moves Forward Without SAVE America Act

Senate Majority Leader John Thune announced Republicans will pass a stand-alone FISA renewal, ignoring President Trump's demand to attach his SAVE America Act voter ID legislation.

Thune Defies Trump on FISA Renewal as Senate Moves Forward Without SAVE America Act

Senate Majority Leader John Thune delivered a rare public rebuke to President Trump on Monday, announcing that Republicans would move forward with a stand-alone renewal of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act without the voter ID provisions Trump demanded be attached.

The South Dakota Republican told reporters the Senate GOP caucus would ignore Trump's Truth Social ultimatum from earlier in the day, in which the president threatened to veto any FISA extension that did not include the SAVE America Act, his signature election integrity legislation requiring proof of citizenship to vote in federal elections.

A Growing Rift Between Trump and Senate Republicans

"We're going to move a clean FISA extension," Thune said. "Section 702 is too important to national security to let it become a political football. It's that important."

The standoff marks the latest evidence of tension between the president and his own party's Senate leadership. Trump has repeatedly pressured Thune to eliminate the 60-vote filibuster threshold to ram through his agenda, but the majority leader has maintained that the votes "aren't there" for such a dramatic rule change.

Section 702 of FISA, which authorizes warrantless surveillance of foreign targets and has been criticized by civil liberties advocates on both sides of the aisle, faces expiration after Congress passed only a 45-day extension in late April. The current deadline leaves lawmakers scrambling to find a path forward.

National Security Concerns Override Political Demands

Republican senators have grown increasingly frustrated with Trump's efforts to tie unrelated legislation to must-pass bills. The SAVE America Act, while popular among the conservative base, has no realistic path to the 60 votes needed to break a Senate filibuster as a stand-alone measure.

Some GOP senators have also expressed private concerns about granting expanded surveillance powers given Trump's nomination of Bill Pulte to serve as acting Director of National Intelligence. Pulte, a controversial choice, has generated bipartisan unease about how FISA authorities might be wielded.

"After pushing an appointee for acting DNI who has generated deep concerns on both sides of the aisle and now demanding that Congress tack the unrelated SAVE Act onto FISA reauthorization, it's fair to ask whether the president actually wants this bill to pass," one senior Republican aide observed.

The Surveillance Debate Continues

Civil liberties organizations including the Electronic Frontier Foundation have called for warrant requirements to be added to any FISA renewal, arguing that the current framework enables unconstitutional surveillance of American citizens who communicate with foreign targets.

Conservative critics of the surveillance state have found themselves in an unusual alliance with progressive Democrats on the issue, though for different reasons. Many Republicans remain haunted by the FBI's flawed FISA applications targeting former Trump campaign adviser Carter Page during the Russia investigation.

Thune's decision to move forward without Trump's blessing represents a calculated gamble that the president will ultimately sign whatever FISA extension reaches his desk rather than allow critical intelligence capabilities to lapse. The majority leader appears to be betting that Trump's bark is worse than his bite when national security is on the line.

The Senate is expected to take up the FISA renewal in the coming days, with the current extension set to expire soon. Whether Trump follows through on his veto threat or accepts the stand-alone bill remains to be seen.