Alaska Democrat Peltola Defeats Sullivan in Ranked Choice Upset
Mary Peltola has won Alaska's Senate race over incumbent Dan Sullivan, giving Democrats their ninth pickup and a 56-seat majority amid controversy over the 'Decoy Dan' candidacy.
Democrat Mary Peltola has defeated incumbent Republican Senator Dan Sullivan in Alaska's ranked choice Senate election, delivering Democrats their ninth Senate seat pickup of 2026 and expanding their majority to 56 seats. The outcome follows weeks of controversy over a second candidate named "Daniel J. Sullivan" appearing on the ballot.
Ranked Choice System Decides Close Race
The race came down to Alaska's ranked choice voting tabulation after no candidate secured a majority of first preference votes. Fox News reported that Peltola and Sullivan were separated by fewer than 700 votes before final ranked choice rounds were counted. The New York Times noted that when no candidate reaches 50 percent of first choice votes, the system eliminates the lowest performer and redistributes their supporters' second choices.
Peltola, who previously represented Alaska's at-large House district from 2022 to 2025, launched her Senate challenge in January 2026. POLITICO characterized her recruitment as "a major candidate win" for Democrats seeking to expand the 2026 Senate map. The Guardian reported that Peltola's campaign made Republicans "nervous" throughout the cycle as polling showed a competitive race.
Decoy Dan Controversy Roils Campaign
The election was overshadowed by allegations surrounding Daniel J. Sullivan, a candidate with the same surname as the incumbent senator who qualified for the general election ballot under Alaska's top four system. Senator Ron Johnson launched a probe into what Republicans called the "Decoy Dan" scandal, demanding records on ballot qualification procedures.
President Trump declared the race "over" before final tabulation, arguing that Senator Sullivan should receive all votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan. The New York Post reported Trump's statement that ranked choice voting "allows voters to make their own" choices, acknowledging the system's design prevents automatic vote consolidation between candidates with similar names.
The Federalist noted that Alaska's ranked choice voting system advances the top four vote getters regardless of party affiliation, creating the possibility for multiple candidates with similar names or backgrounds to appear on general election ballots. National Review spotlighted the controversy and examined ballot access procedures.
Implications for Senate Control
Peltola's victory gives Democrats 56 Senate seats, their largest majority since 2009. The expanded margin provides Democrats with additional cushion for legislative priorities and judicial confirmations in the next Congress. Lisa Murkowski, the senior Republican senator from Alaska, had backed Sullivan over her "longtime ally" Peltola during the campaign, according to Alaska's News Source.